Directed by: Manu Boyer
Written by: Avery O. Williams
Starring: Paige Hurd (Laura Cowan), Stephen Bishop (Musa Muhammed), Brad James, Shanica Knowles
This harrowing Lifetime made-for-TV drama tells the true story of Laura Cowan, a mother who, after her husband's arrest, tragically finds herself and her children held captive in a garage by a family acquaintance. The film is part of Lifetime’s “Ripped from the Headlines” lineup and premiered on January 18, 2025 .
Struggling after her husband’s imprisonment, Laura (Paige Hurd) moves in with Musa (Stephen Bishop), a well‑meaning family friend What starts as an act of kindness quickly devolves into a nightmare: they’re locked in a garage for nearly four years, enduring starvation, physical and sexual abuse, and total isolation The turning point comes when Laura secretly passes a note to a postal clerk, igniting their rescue
-
Paige Hurd delivers a determined, deeply sympathetic portrayal of Laura. Her performance captures the unwavering resolve of a mother fighting for her family’s survival
-
Stephen Bishop is chilling as Musa—initially charming, later revealing a controlling zealotry. Critics described his character as resembling “a cult leader”
-
Supporting cast, including Shanica Knowles and the children, effectively heighten the tension of the abusive household
Manu Boyer’s direction leans into claustrophobic intensity—every shadow and silence echoes Laura’s despair. The film stays mostly confined to the garage, portraying in stark detail the oppressive conditions of captivity . Screenwriter Avery O. Williams keeps a tight focus on Laura’s perspective, foregrounding her survival instinct, though some narrative questions—like why neighbors/loved ones didn’t notice sooner—remain unanswered
This is no standard crime drama — it’s a story of endurance, maternal love, and ultimate empowerment. Laura isn’t portrayed just as a victim, but as a survivor—and now an advocate against domestic violence . The film offers no easy comfort, but its emotional payoff is powerful when Laura reclaims her life.
-
IMDb users rate it around 6.7/10
-
Letterboxd reviews are mixed—some call it “incompetent on every level, but not completely unwatchable,” others find it deeply affecting
-
Lifetime Uncorked gave a balanced view:
“Paige Hurd does really go work here,” praising its gripping portrayal of survival
Girl in the Garage is a tough, emotionally raw film that doesn’t shy away from the horrors of captivity or the strength needed to escape. Though it suffers from some Lifetime clichés and raises lingering narrative gaps, the central performance by Paige Hurd and the true-story foundation give it a resonant, truth‑bearing power. It’s not light viewing—but for those looking for a story of resilience and motherhood, it delivers.
