Genre: Slasher Horror
Director/Writer: Corbin Timbrook
Runtime: ~78 minutes
IMDb Rating: 3.6/10
Blake Sinclair, a struggling writer, retreats to a secluded mountain town called Northdale to overcome writer’s block—and finds herself stalked by a mysterious killer who’s already claimed multiple victims. As bodies mount and paranoia sets in, Blake must fight for survival while questioning the motives behind each vicious act
-
Short, Taut Runtime
At just under 80 minutes, Why? moves briskly from threat to chase. It respects viewers' time without unnecessary detours . -
Familiar Slasher Comfort
For fans of classic 1980s horror like Friday the 13th, this film delivers recognizable beats: isolated cabin, creeping tension, masked killer, and bloody reveals
-
Predictable Plot & Thin Thrills
Most critics agree the film is far too formulaic, delivering straightforward slash-and-stalk sequences with no real suspense or scare value -
Subpar Acting & Characters
Performances are widely described as flat, with lead Blake often making “truly stupid decisions,” making it hard for audiences to connect No Sympathy for Victims
The killer’s motivations are obscure, and the victims lack backstory or development—making their fates feel hollow -
Weak Sound Design & Tension
One reviewer called it the worst in indie horror, criticizing the sound mix and score for draining any remaining suspense -
IMDb Average: 3.6/10 from over 1,000 voters
-
Reddit & Reviews: Common reactions include:
-
“It’s a bad movie… predictable, boring… not even in a funny way”
“What is Lance Henriksen doing… taking bit parts in ordure like this?” -
A few niche fans champion it:
“Like Friday the 13th… I liked it, and I recommend you watch it.”
As a low-budget throwback, Why? checks some vintage slasher boxes and is watchable for genre completists. However, limited scares, weak characters, and amateurish production keep it from thriving. With only fleeting tension and no emotional investment, it’s ultimately forgettable.
Rating: ⭐⭐☆☆☆ (2/5)
-
Die-hard slasher fans curious about modern indie takes.
-
Viewers looking for a short, wooden-cabin horror flick to fill an evening.
Skip it if you want tension, unique kills, or compelling characters—Why? fails to ask or answer any real question beyond its title.
